Showing posts with label history. Show all posts
Showing posts with label history. Show all posts

Saturday, 17 September 2016

Imperium by Robert Harris

Imperium by Robert Harris, 2006, 2009

Imperium

This book in many respects seems to have been written with Hollywood already in mind. It is vivid, action-packed, and the episodes often almost beg to be filmed as scenes.
All the characters are carefully drawn and differ convincingly and memorably from one another. In particular, Pompey is the larger-than-life type, so that reading his “scenes” one can feel him as almost physically present. The episode of the pirates – the sudden menace that made it “necessary” to grant Pompey extra powers to deal with them, which he then did with literally incredible rapidity – was strongly reminiscent of Tony Blair and Saddam Hussein’s WMDs in 2003.
Robert Harris has clearly done a lot of research. He refers to this briefly at the end of this book, and in more detail at the end of the third book in the series, Dictator. His chosen approach is to present, and to some extent fictionalise, Cicero’s life and the events that ended the Roman Republic, as a modern-day political thriller. The book is easy and compelling reading. This means that people who have no idea about and perhaps minimal interest in history as a subject (including some of us, who weren’t sure whether the book was set in the fifth century BC, fifth century AD, or somewhere in between), can read about it and acquire a fair picture of what went on.
This approach, of course, has its problems. Anachronisms are not altogether absent: references to a “drawing-room”, and others.
There is also the risk of being carried away by enjoyment of the story and suspending critical judgement.
Another problem is that some of the episodes that Harris does invent are totally unbelievable from start to finish – especially where he has Tiro (Cicero’s private secretary) taking copious notes of a top-secret meeting of Cicero’s enemies while hiding in a hole behind a tapestry.
The choice of Tiro as first-person narrator seemed in some ways rather laboured, in that it involves inventing more or less likely reasons why he was present at all the episodes he describes, and how it is that he remembers them or has all his notes of them. N.B. notes were normally made by scratching on wax tablets – not a method that really lent itself to extensive long-term preservation, particularly not through the various exiles and escapes that Tiro experienced in his life.
There are some wonderful quotations. “If it’s gratitude you want, get a dog.” “The ability to listen to bores requires stamina…” “Gossip is a trade…” “There can never have been anyone quite so worldly in their pursuit of unworldliness as Titus Pomponius Atticus.” “Since when has idiocy been a bar to advancement in politics?” “The trouble with Lucius is that he thinks politics is a fight for justice. Politics is a profession.”

What the book brings home is the sheer brutality of the ancient world, which it is not, unfortunately, impossible to parallel in today’s world. Worst of all of these, in many ways, was Verres’ hideous underground prison in Sicily. All of Verres’ crimes as discovered and detailed by Cicero are fact.

Saturday, 6 February 2016

God's Secret Agents by Alice Hogge

God’s Secret Agents: Queen Elizabeth’s Forbidden Priests and the Hatching of the Gunpowder Plot by Alice Hogge. HarperCollins 2006.

Front Cover


A totally absorbing and, for many of us, un-put-downable book. Hogge herself is not a Catholic, but she came across the story of the Catholic priests who came to England in the second half of the sixteenth century, when Catholicism was being stamped out and it was a capital crime to celebrate Mass or to shelter a Catholic priest. Hogge was fascinated by the doings of these clandestine Catholics, and started to research the story and finally to write it up in book form.

Her research is painstaking thorough and detailed, and she writes very well, in a simple, matter-of-fact style appropriate to the historical nature of the book, but never becoming boring.

The cover of the paperback edition of this book shows a wooden panel with someone peering through a knothole in the wood from the page behind. The book uses historical documents to tell the story of the proscribed Roman Catholic priests who came on the “English Mission” during the reign of Queen Elizabeth the First and King James the First and Sixth. These were often the sons of Catholic families, or else converts, who had gone abroad to train for the priesthood, been ordained, and returned to minister to Catholics (“Recusants”, as refusing the government-imposed new religion) and, where possible, receive Anglicans back into the Catholic faith.

It was, however, a crime for a Catholic priest to minister in England, and these men knew what was awaiting them: a life on the run, from one hiding-place to another, hunted by spies who were hopeful of receiving a bounty for information leading to their capture. (Much of Hogge’s detail comes from reports written by these same spies for their masters, and still preserved in archives and other historical collections.) After the Pope excommunicated Elizabeth I and released her subjects from their allegiance, Catholic priests were considered by the English government to be in the pay of a hostile foreign power, and executed as traitors, by hanging, drawing and quartering. First, however, they would be tortured to extract information on their fellow-Catholics.


The book does not hide any of the gruesome details. Nor does it soften the difficulties that the “English mission” encountered, such as the factions and disunity within the Catholic community, and the number of priests and lay-men who recanted their faith for fear of torture and death. The characters that stand out, however, are magnificent men like Fr John Gerard, and Nicholas Owen, whose ingeniously constructed hiding-places often enabled a hunted priest to survive for another adventurous episode, or even escape altogether. And, of course, Fr Henry Garnet, who had the well-nigh impossible job of keeping the Mission functioning, and who was arrested as a result of the Gunpowder Plot, convicted of misprision of treason (though he denied to the end that he had known about it) and executed.

Sunday, 9 February 2014

The Hare with Amber Eyes: A Hidden Inheritance by Edmund de Waal

The Hare with Amber Eyes: A Hidden Inheritance. Edmund de Waal, Vintage, London, 2011.



Readers’ reactions to the book differed widely according to their past experience, among other things.
The writing is good, although the beginning in particular seems slow-moving and quite hard to get through. The author tends to write in short, terse sentences, with plenty of historic-present-tense verbs. Quite easy to parody, but basically well crafted and sustains interest. An interesting note in the preface explores the author’s reasons or motivations for writing and especially what does not motivate him (p. 15).

It is a book about a journey, or rather journeying: both that of the netsuke collection, and EdW’s own. For the netsuke there is a process of attachment and detachment along the way, being acquired, owned, valued or not valued differently, and passed on to someone else. The author takes you with him on his journey. He does not know where the journey is going to lead him, and neither do you. A totally enjoyable process, even for those who generally like books with a plot. There isn’t one, but by the end of it the reader has acquired a fair amount of meaningful historical information and has been on a journey of discovery; the netsuke are the thread that holds the whole thing together.

The author’s journey takes him notably to Tokyo, Paris, Vienna, Kovecses (Hungary) and Odessa, in the process of journeying into the lives of his family’s past members. It is not a travel book, because of the tremendous sense of place.

It is a book that needs to be re-read to get the most out of it as there is so much to take in. Not only to read again but to study and discuss. It is a fantastic angle on the history, especially the social history, of Europe in the 19th and early 20th century, and Japan in and after World War 2.

Eileen, an artist herself, enjoyed the beautifully crafted writing, and the rich masses of information about different artistic styles and movements in the course of the book. You identify with EdW’s appreciation of this little work of art that is a netsuke, so fine and small, over which a craftsmen had spent ages: they are objets d’art and worth studying for themselves. The value of a thing is all the human effort that has gone into making them. He spends time on the tactile value of the netsuke, to others and to him as a craftsman himself. This was especially interesting to Eileen because of her mother’s belongings: she bought things carefully, individually, planning what she was going to buy and whom for – a Wedgewood dinner-service she wanted her son to have, etc.: “This is beautiful,” she would think, “and I want it for so-and-so…”

Readers can appreciate Edmund de Waal’s sensitivity; this appears to be a tendency inherited from his ancestors and family, and he wants his children to have the netsuke; at the end of the book he installs a vitrine for them at home. All of this is in stark contrast to our current pervasive throw-away culture. The book makes one realise how unpleasant and alienating this culture is; and to want things that can be valued. Carelessness breaks and spoils things; the approach of the artist helps everyone to re-learn a love of things that have value and meaning. Costly and beautiful and material things have a meaning. There are so many reasons for valuing an object: De Waal really explores what happens when people value an object; just as an artist he didn’t want the things he had made to be lost or thrown away.

The story of the netsuke takes us to World War 2 Europe, and how the Jews – in this case the Ephrussi family of Vienna – were forcibly detached from their prized possessions. It is an effective introduction to what used to be called “the Jewish question”: why the Jews were disliked by so many members of their host countries: the book does not explain it so much as exploring it. It was particularly helpful to readers who had already seen Simon Schama’s programmes “The Story of the Jews”, especially the one about the Enlightenment. EdW’s family were assimilated Jews – Charles Ephrussi in 19th-century Paris; Viktor and Elizabeth in Vienna – they professed no religion, but what mattered was the clan, the family.


Other readers may find that there is no character in the book that they sympathise or can identify with in any way. The human angle is deliberately undeveloped, the relationships are dealt with from a historical angle. One may miss the fleshing-out that a historical-fiction approach would have brought; EdW restricts himself to appreciative history with a minimum of speculation.

Wednesday, 24 July 2013

Sisters of Sinai, Janet Soskice



Janet Soskice, Sisters of Sinai: How Two Lady Adventurers Found the Hidden Gospels, Vintage Books, 2010.


This book was a chance suggestion that turned out to be one of the most successful books we have read so far in terms of enjoyment, discussion and “reader engagement”. Book-club members did various forms of research on the writer and on the subjects of the book and all of this was brought up at the meeting.
The two “lady adventurers” were the twins Agnes and Margaret Smith of Irvine, Scotland, born on 11th January 1843. They were brought up as Presbyterians and both of them firmly believed and practised their faith all their lives. In a way their Presbyterian faith could be said to be what drives and inspires – rather even than simply guides – their whole lives. They inherited a large fortune, and as Soskice explains, their Presbyterianism told them that this was for a purpose: they could neither give it away, nor spend it on themselves. So they travelled, researched ancient manuscripts, endowed  a Presbyterian college (Westminster College) at Cambridge, and started the Boys’ Brigade.

So many puzzling features of their lives now made sense. Their money, for instance – never unwelcome, but what was it for? Giving it all away, St Francis-like, had never been a Presbyterian option. Riches (especially riches, like theirs, acquired almost accidentally) must be intended to play some part in the providential plan.
Now it was clear that they did have vocations, and ones for which their life experiences entirely suited them. (p. 252)

Some people found the book rather heavy going at the beginning, but soon became engrossed in the story. Agnes and Margaret’s father (their mother died two weeks after they were born) promised them that for every new language they learned, he would take them to visit the country where it was spoken. They made the most of their amazing gift for languages (and their capacity for serious study and hard work) to learn modern European languages and then went on to more exotic ones, Greek, Arabic, Syriac, and more. It was notable that they had no mother to teach them a woman’s place in the nineteenth-century world, i.e. to hold them back and limit their horizons...
The book covers the whole of their lives, but dwells especially on their journeys to St Catherine’s Monastery in the Sinai Desert. They went there because they had been told by a friendly professor at Cambridge (where they had settled) that he had visited the monastery and seen a manuscript there which might prove to be extremely important, but had been unable to examine it. While they were there, Agnes discovered a battered old chunk of pages all stuck together, and realised it was a palimpsest of the Bible – a palimpsest being a manuscript whose original writing had been scraped or washed off and something else written on top. With careful examination and sometimes special treatment, the original writing can be made out. It turned out to be an extraordinarily early manuscript of the whole Bible in Syriac. Agnes and Margaret, helped by the monk-librarian, started to photograph the whole manuscript page by page. They had to come back a year later, this time accompanied by more scholars, to complete the work of making a good copy of the whole manuscript.
The whole story is fascinating and it takes a book to do it full justice. In addition, we hear about the travelling conditions for European visitors in the Middle East at that time. The story is told with no dramatization, but very clearly and vividly, and the difficulties they had to tackle all the way are very real, so much so that it is quite distressing. They quickly got used to riding on camels – and how the sisters got on with the Greek Orthodox monks. They were of course totally ignorant of this form of religion, and one Sunday when the monks were going by in solemn procession Agnes thought that she ought to shake hands with the Prior. Read the episode on p. 139! They were, nevertheless, open-minded and respectful despite their complete inability to understand. 
Another interesting feature that comes up in this extremely rich and eventful story is the terrible way that some academics treated others – nothing has changed in this respect, alas! Obviously there were also some who were kind, generous and helpful, though. Plus the atrocious plundering of manuscripts that went on – again, plus ça change...
As for the twins themselves, there is a lot more we would like to know about them but don’t, simply because the twins didn’t write about it. You get a real sense of their self-restraint, privacy, – from their point of view even decency – in that they don’t let it all hang out, or go in for either navel-gazing or self-advertising. That itself tells you a lot about them.


Sunday, 9 December 2012

The Olive Grove by Deborah Rohan

The Olive Grove – a Palestinian Story, by Deborah Rohan. London: Saqi, 2008.

Front Cover

This book will leave the reader wanting to do some research and find out more about Israel/Palestine, to get a larger picture of the rights and wrongs. It is hard to be sure which parts of the book are historically accurate, and which are fiction; a lot of background knowledge would be needed to be able to sort it out. The book does not actually claim to be history, but a fictionalised account of one family’s story – though my library, interestingly, has it firmly in the “History” section, and large parts of the book are devoted to people explaining Palestine’s situation, and its causes, to one another at length.

To start on a positive note, this book is a good read: the story is engaging and claims one's interest. However, it is not good literature. Some of the incidents, and many of the characters’ reactions, seem stilted and contrived. The prose is patchy at best, often hopelessly awkward, and sometimes the author simply can’t work out the structure of her own sentences, as on p. 97: “He had repeatedly blamed himself for Hagop’s departure on his own need to have tobacco.” Rohan also has the widespread American habit of using the first word that comes to mind, without checking what it really means. E.g. “languish” when she really meant “pause” or simply “lie”: again and again, “Haniya languished in the doorway”, “olives languished on a plate”. Or “donned”: “Raji spotted the soldiers donned in red and white headdresses”. There are plenty of other examples.

It does not convey the reality of Palestinian life and culture, or make the Palestinian character come alive – rather than being a “Palestinian Story”, as its subtitle claims, it’s a family story, and the family is an American one with Palestinian bits added on for decoration. All the characters are drawn as Americans, which comes across as completely out of place – e.g., on p. 66, Hagop the Armenian says to Kamel who is reproaching himself for leaving Hagop to be attacked by two Turks, “Don’t do that to yourself, Kamel. Things happen. You were there for me.” This is a late-twentieth-century American talking, not an early-twentieth-century Armenian. The whole atmosphere of the book is very Western. There is scene after scene of the Moghrabi children playing, which can end up being merely tedious; the author was presumably trying to build up a picture of family life in Palestine, but lacked the skill to do it successfully. A much better picture of another culture is achieved in Three Cups of Tea by Greg Mortenson, poorly written though it is.

The action in The Olive Grove is slow and often plodding. Even when Kamel is in prison, there is not much of a feel of what it is like because only the most obvious and superficial, almost clichéd, details are given. Fair enough, the author was re-working what she had been told by Hamzi, and maybe didn’t have very much to go on – but did she try to find out? The reader repeatedly wonders whether Rohan had done any investigation or information-gathering at all – did she have any idea of the real scene in a Palestinian refugee camp? She talks about the stench – but then Hamzi got used to it, and that is all. She doesn’t explain how these destitute people could find money to buy his cigarettes, yet he seems to have supported himself by selling them.

A question about the Moghrabi family which does not seem to be explained in the book is why they were not practising Muslims. The reader also notices that the Moghrabis do not represent the majority of Palestinians, in that they are a rich family, and even in exile in Lebanon, after their money has run out, they are still only relatively poor – they never live in the refugee camp themselves.

The Palestinian people in the book appear too perfect, and the Jewish people and others are demonized.  It could be a good book for softening attitudes towards Islam, but leads one to dislike the Jews intensely – though it does distinguish between (bad) Zionists and “good Jews”, in the person of Rabbi Moussa.

Other “good” characters in the book are the Arab Christians who hid and protected their Jewish or Palestinian neighbours at the risk of their own lives.  Dr White, the American director of Hamzi’s school in Lebanon, championed Hamzi and tried to help his Palestinian pupils react positively instead of going for retaliation and revenge.

The book raises the whole question of Jewish identity, how it comes to be wrapped up with that particular piece of land – the Promised Land – and the question of anti-Semitism and the results of the Second World War. If the Palestinians are actually Philistines, then their claim to that land goes back even further than the claim of the Jews does – though the Jews’ claim is not based on antiquity so much as a God-given promise. However, the Jews in Israel appear to be Zionists first and worshippers of God only a very poor second, if that. The book does not mention the fact that Jews and Palestinians are, by all accounts, very closely related, but this is a fact that it is important to bear in mind.

Readers who come to this book knowing nothing about the British in Palestine will be shocked at how they behaved, not only on the large scale, but also in the story of Lieutenant Bainbridge and Mahmoud’s and Kamel’s rifle (which ends on pp. 280-1). The picture is of arrogant British supremacy: “I want your property and I am stronger than you, so I’m going to have it.” In dealing with the situation in Palestine after the Second World War, the British clearly did not know what they were dealing with. They were seriously to blame for this, because they should have taken pains to find out since they had assumed responsibility for the country. They made and broke promises to both sides, both the Jews and the Palestinians.
It is also clear that the UN is at least as much to blame for the situation of Israel/Palestine as the British.

The same achingly desperate story of wrongs could be written and told by a Jewish family. Stories of atrocities by Palestinians are part of what every Jewish person knows. It is worth bearing in mind, however, that this book was written in America for Americans, who are used to Israel being “right” because the US supports it (not the other way round). Do we get a slightly more balanced picture in the UK? At least we hear a lot more from the Palestinian side. Neither side (taken as a whole) can ever see that two wrongs don’t make a right. However, Kamel and Hamzi are “enlightened” Palestinians and can see it more clearly than most. Although they don’t often make the international news, there are people on both sides who are working to unite the two communities at the local level, just as there were people doing the same in Northern Ireland throughout the Troubles.

Finally, there is an absolutely amazing episode on pp. 420-431. Fifty years on, Hamzi, with his adult daughter, goes back to Israel-Palestine on a brief visit from America. They go to his former family home and find it is a café, owned by a Palestinian. When he tells the owner, George, who he is,

George’s face grows ashen. He stands up, nods an ‘excuse me’ to Ruba, and leaves the room. Moments later he returns, holding a set of keys. ‘Please, sir, the restaurant is yours.’
‘What? I don’t understand.’
‘If you have returned to your home, after these many years, I will gladly turn over my business to you. I do not wish to prosper from anyone so hurt by the Israeli occupation. My family could not flee. For many years we suffered, but at least we had the good fortune to remain in our country. Now we are allowed to run our own businesses.’ He nods his head again. ‘Consider the restaurant yours.’

Hamzi has to refuse, of course, since he is only being allowed into Israel on a short tourist visa. Did the author (and did Hamzi himself) see that this episode was an astonishing mirror image of the whole miserable question that lies behind the book? After many years of bitter exile, the Jews came back to what had once been their homeland. The present inhabitants, the Palestinians, who had a perfect legal and historical right to the land, could either welcome them as long-lost brothers and hand over the land to them,… or resist them bitterly. The Jews could have treated the Palestinians as friends and neighbours, each side aiming to share generously and equably and treat the other with humanity, fairness, and compassion. But because each side saw the other from the start not as brothers but as enemies – invaders, occupiers – the story of Israel/Palestine has been tragic from the start and continues to be one of hatred and killing, with no real solution imaginable even now.

Sunday, 18 March 2012

Brixton Beach by R. Tearne, William Wilberforce by W Hague, and list

Feb-March 2012: Brixton Beach, Roma Tearne
We had a brilliant meeting about Brixton Beach, further enhanced by a delicious lamb curry with dhal, and illustrated books, old and new, about Sri Lanka, brought along by Ranmali.
The characterisation is excellent, the different people in the book are well-rounded, convincing characters whom you feel you have actually met. Most striking of all were the descriptions of the beauty of Sri Lanka / Ceylon, especially the sea, with the light and the colours. It didn't come as a surprise that the writer is also a painter. People also liked the descriptions of eating and the different types of food, which Ranmali was able to explain. She herself was very struck by seeing in print, for the first time, things that she had always heard - anay, "men!" for "mate", and others.
What some people really disliked about the book was the fact that it went from one tragedy to another. Every time you thought that there was a chance of things working out well for someone, wham! down came the next disaster. It wasn't at all clear why Tearne had called the different sections of the book 'Bel Canto', 'Paradiso', 'Inferno', 'Purgatorio', and 'Bel Canto' again, because the disasters occur throughout. It is not a book to read if you are feeling down. We discussed the question of the Buddhist world-view, which might have been the reason why the characters seemed to do nothing to try and improve a bad or hopeless situation, when they could have taken action to change things. The saddest part was Alice's marriage - both of them wanted it to succeed but they didn't work at it and the result was the marriage fell apart.
Bee was a general favourite, and his relationship with his wife Kamala was beautiful, based on real understanding, acceptance, and friendship, that had matured into love. Both of them were sincerely good people committed to each other, and to trying to help those in need. Janake too was a realistic, lovely, caring person. A striking thing was the representation of the Sea House as a living person, and then, after the assassinations, as a dead one.
Dec2011 -Feb 2012, William Wilberforce, William Hague
Although I don't think any of us had actually got to the end of the book, everyone had got a lot out of it. One bookclubber asked whether Hague could have reduced the background content by 10 – 20% and without losing the book's significance, so that the book could be read in a reasonable amount of time?
People were really enthused about WW's character: his honesty and integrity first of all, and his charm and gift for friendship, and his persistence: the fact that although he kept on getting beaten, he never even considered giving up. And he didn't do it out of natural stubbornness - he really suffered over the way that people who'd been captured as slaves were being treated, year after year, and was determined to help them. We wondered someone with his gifts, principles and determination could have the same effect on Britain today - what he did was comparable to campaigning for a reversal of the abortion laws now. Today's media, of course, is a factor that didn't exist in his time.
We also liked the bit about how he got swamped with letters and never actually got to the end of answering them because he wasn't business-like about it at all!
A really good thing about the book was that the author is someone who's been in Parliament all his life so he knows exactly what he's talking about - what it's like, what the issues are, how it worked then as well as now.
We needed the historical background filling in to understand the situation WW and Pitt were in - the ongoing state of war against France, the huge amounts being paid by Britain to other countries just to keep them in the fight, and the fear of a revolution in England like the French one.
We had a long and interesting digression about slavery today. Apparently the second largest "business" in the world today in terms of money is slavery and people-trafficking! And unlike the 18th century it is completely invisible. That would be another field for a "modern Wilberforce" to work on.
September-October, The Translator, Daoud Hari
July-September 2011, The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society, Mary Ann Schaffer and Annie Barrows; AND I Capture the Castle, Dodie Smith
June-July 2011, The House of Special Purpose, John Boyne
March-May 2011, To Kill a Mockingbird, Harper Lee
February- March 2011Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mother, Amy Chua
February-March 2011 Silas Marner, George Eliot
Jan-Feb 2011 The Elegance of the Hedgehog, Muriel Barbery